Make a Submission
No. XLIII/1 (2021)
Articles

Debt bondage in human trafficking: US agriculture and Thailand fisheries primed for labour exploitation

Niewola za długi: rolnictwo Stanów Zjednoczonych i rybołówstwo Tajlandii gotowe na pracę przymusową

PDF
  • Sudarat Musikawong,
  • Panida Rzonca
Sudarat Musikawong
Mahidol University, Institute of Population and Social Research, Associate Professor of Sociology
Panida Rzonca
Thai Community Develop Center, Directing Attorne
DOI: https://doi.org/10.7420/AK2021.11

Published 2023-02-15

Keywords

  • trafficking,
  • debt-bondage,
  • corporate social responsibility,
  • Global Horizons,
  • Thailand,
  • fishing,
  • agriculture

How to Cite

Musikawong, S., & Rzonca, P. (2023). Debt bondage in human trafficking: US agriculture and Thailand fisheries primed for labour exploitation: Niewola za długi: rolnictwo Stanów Zjednoczonych i rybołówstwo Tajlandii gotowe na pracę przymusową. Archives of Criminology, (XLIII/1), 169–193. https://doi.org/10.7420/AK2021.11
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Crossref
Scopus
Google Scholar
Europe PMC

Abstract

There is a need for a transnational framework that would redefine labour trafficking in terms of debt bondage and challenge the privileges of legal contracts at the expense of migrant workers’ human and labour rights. We argue that anti-trafficking legislation in the US and Thailand is expansive in definition, but its application is too restrictive to deliver justice to the victims. The debt-labour industry easily becomes a form of transnational labour trafficking. We examine Thailand as an origin and destination country for labour trafficking through two cases involving the US and Thailand though a Marxist and liberal analysis that considers critical race theory. The limitations in which these cases could not achieve full justice represent the challenges for transnational labour rights for noncitizen migrant workers. We examine the Global Horizons agricultural labour case, 2002–2012, and Thailand’s fishing sector, which led to its Tier 3 ranking in the 2014 Trafficking in Persons Report. This report was used in international campaigns to pressurise corporate industries and retailers to change their code of conduct, necessitating considerations of the effectiveness of supply chain responsibility.

PDF

References

  1. Agencies of the President’s Interagency Task Force to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons (2019). United States Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons. Available online: https://www.state.gov/agencies-of-the-presidents-interagency-task-force-to-monitor-and-combat-trafficking-in-persons/ [10.02.2021].
  2. Alliance to End Slavery and Trafficking (2020). ATEST Calls on the Department of Justice and the Department of Homeland Security to Re-examine their Anti-Trafficking Policing Policies, Endslaveryandtrafficking.org. Available online: https://endslaveryandtrafficking.org/atest-calls-on-the-department-of-justice-and-the-department-of-homeland-security-to-re-examine-their-anti-trafficking-policing-policies/ [14.09.2020].
  3. Asanok v. Million Express Manpower (2007). United States District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina Western Division. USA.
  4. Azis A. and Wahyudi R. (2020). ʻImperfect victims and an imperfect protocol: Reflecting on the trafficking experiences of Indonesian Migrant Fishermenʼ. Journal of Human Trafficking 6(2), pp. 156–167.
  5. Bales K. (2008). Ending Slavery: How We Free Today's Slaves. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
  6. Banki S. (2016). ʻPrecarity of place: A complement to the growing precariat literatureʼ. In M.T. Johnson (ed.) Precariat: Labour, Work and Politics. Routledge, pp. 66–79.
  7. Barber v. Nestle USA, INC (2018). Case Opinion from the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. USA.
  8. Belser P. (2005). Forced Labor and Human Trafficking: Estimating the Profits. Declaration of Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work. Geneva: International Labour Organization.
  9. Bhambra G.K., Medien K. and Tilley L. (2020). ‘Theory for a global age: From nativism to neoliberalism and beyond’. Current Sociology Monograph 68(2), pp. 137–148.
  10. Bowe J. (2010). Bound for America, Motherjones.com. Available online: https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2010/04/immigration-law-indentured-servitude/ [28.01.2021].
  11. Bracy K., Lul B. and Roe-Sepowitz D. (2019). ʻA four-year analysis of labor trafficking cases in the United States: Exploring characteristics and labor trafficking patternsʼ. Journal of Human Trafficking 7(1), pp. 35–52.
  12. California Legislature (2010). The California Transparency in Supply Chains Act. SB657. Sacramento, California: California Department of Justice.
  13. Caraway N. (2006). ʻHuman rights and existing contradictions in Asia-Pacific human trafficking politics and discourseʼ. Tulane Journal of International and Comparative Law 14(1), pp. 295–316.
  14. Chacón J.M. (2006). ʻMisery and myopia: Understanding the failures of U.S. efforts to stop human traffickingʼ. Fordham Law Review 74, pp. 2977–3040.
  15. Chacón J.M. (2017). ʻHuman trafficking, immigration regulation, and sub-federal criminalizationʼ. New Criminal Law Review 20(1), pp. 96–129.
  16. Chantavanich S. and Germershausen A. (2000). ʻIntroduction: Research on Thai migrant workers in East and Southeast Asiaʼ. In S. Chantavanich, A. Germershausen and A. Beesey (eds.) Thai Migrant Workers in East and Southeast Asia 1996-1997. Bangkok: Asia Research Center for Migration, Chulalongkorn University, pp. 2–9.
  17. Chantavanich S. and Makcharoen P. (2008). ʻThailandʼ. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal 17, pp. 391–411.
  18. Chantavanich S., Laodumrongchai S., Vangsiriphisal P., Kamonpetch A., Makcharoen P. and Kaochan P. (2010). Research Report on Understanding Recruitment Industry in Thailand. Bangkok: Chulalongkorn University.
  19. Chantavanich S., Yothinneeranath P., Kuikaew P., Makcharoen P. and Neelapaichit K. (2020). Report. Policy Management & Knowledge Transfer to Solve the Problems of illegal, unreported and unregulated IUU Fishing. Chulalongkorn University Conference.
  20. Chatterjee P. (2010). Global horizons indicted for human trafficking, Corpwatch.org. Available online: https://corpwatch.org/article/global-horizons-indicted-human-trafficking-0 [19.02.2021].
  21. Chomchai P. (2000). ʻMigration of Thai workers in the 1990s: Towards a synthesis of economic theories and trends in migration researchʼ. In S. Chantavanich, A. Germershausen and A. Beesey (ed.) Thai Migrant Workers in East and Southeast Asia 1996-1997. Bangkok: Asia Research Center for Migration, Chulalongkorn University, pp. 28–57.
  22. CP Foods commits on non-violation of human rights in all forms (2019), Bangkokpost.com. Available online: https://www.bangkokpost.com/thailand/pr/1794064/cp-foods-commits-on-non-violation-of-human-rights-in-all-forms [19.02.2021].
  23. Davidson L. (2010). A story of modern slavey in Utah, Deseretnews.com. Available online: https://www.deseret.com/2010/8/15/20134636/a-story-of-modern-slavery-in-utah#circle-four-farms-near-milford-utah [28.01.2021].
  24. Department of Employment (2003). Yearbook of Employment Statistics. Bangkok: Ministry of Labor of Thailand.
  25. Department of Employment (2013). Yearbook of Employment Statistics. Bangkok: Ministry of Labor of Thailand.
  26. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Global Horizons, Inc. (2011). No. Civil Action No: CV-11–3045-EFS. US District Court.
  27. Fudge J. (2018). ʻModern slavery, unfree labour and the labour market: The social dynamics of legal characterizationʼ. Social & Legal Studies 27(4), pp. 414–434.
  28. Godsey N. (2011-2012). ʻThe next step: Why non-governmental organizations must take a growing role in the new global anti-trafficking frameworkʼ. Regent Journal of International Law 8, pp. 27–55.
  29. Greenpeace (2016). Made in Taiwan: Government Failure and Illegal, Abusive and Criminal Fisheries. Taiwan: Greenpeace East Asia Taipei.
  30. Hall M.L. (2001-2002). ʻDefending the Rights of H-2A Farmworkersʼ. North Carolina Journal of International Law and Commercial Regulations 27, pp. 521–538.
  31. Huguet J. (2014). An assessment of the MOU process for recruiting migrant workers for employment in Thailand. Ministry of Labour, ILO, IOM Meeting. Bangkok: ILO.
  32. Human Rights Watch (2018). Hidden Chains: Rights Abuses and Forced Labor in Thailand’s Fishing Industry. Washington D.C.: Human Rights Watch.
  33. ILO (2009). Operational Indicators of Trafficking in Human Beings. Geneva: United Nations. Available online: https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/@ed_norm/@declaration/documents/publication/wcms_105023.pdf [17.02.2021].
  34. ILO (2011a). Building a sustainable future with decent work in Asia and the Pacific. Available online: http://www.ilo.int/global/meetings-and-events/regional-meetings/asia/aprm-15/reports/WCMS_151860/lang--en/index.htm [19.02.2021].
  35. ILO (2011b). Report of the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations, 101st Session. Geneva: United Nations. Available online: https://www.ilo.org/global/standards/applying-and-promoting-international-labour-standards/committee-of-experts-on-the-application-of-conventions-and-recommendations/lang--en/index.htm [19.02.2021].
  36. ILO (2013). Employment practices and working conditions in Thailand's fishing sector. GMS Triangle Project. Geneva: ILO. Available online: https://www.voced.edu.au/content/ngv%3A58195 [19.02.2021].
  37. ILO (2014). Protocol for the implementation and enforcement of the Forced Labor Convention. Available online: https://www.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:12100:0::NO::P12100_ILO_CODE:P029 [19.02.2021].
  38. ILO (2017a). Food and agriculture global value chains: Drivers and constraints for occupational safety and health improvement. Geneva: ILO. Available online: https://www.ilo.org/safework/projects/WCMS_588089/lang--en/index.htm [19.02.2021].
  39. ILO (2017b). Global estimates of modern slavery: Forced labour and forced marriage. Geneva. Available online: https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/@dgreports/@dcomm/documents/publication/wcms_575479.pdf [17.02.2021].
  40. ILO (2020). Recruitment fees and related costs: What migrant workers from Cambodia, the Lao People’s Democratic Republic, and Myanmar pay to work in Thailand. Geneva: ILO. Available online: https://www.ilo.org/asia/publications/WCMS_740400/lang--en/index.htm [19.02.2021].
  41. Inglis S.C. (2001). ʻExpanding international and national protections against trafficking for forced labor using a human rights frameworkʼ. Buffalo Human Rights Law Review 7, pp. 55–104.
  42. Institutional Review Board No. 11-13-045. USA: Siena College.
  43. Itoga S. (1996). Labor issues and APEC liberalization: Case of Thailand and Malaysia. Institute of Developing Economies - Japan External Trade Organization. Available online: http://www.ide.go.jp/library/English/Publish/Download/Apec/pdf/1996_08.pdf [19.02.2021].
  44. Jagars N. and Conny R. (2014). ʻPrevention of human trafficking for labor exploitation: The role of corporationsʼ. Northwestern Journal of International Human Rights 12(1), pp. 47–73.
  45. Jampawan W. (2018). ʻPrevention of trafficking in persons for forced sea fishery work in Thailandʼ. Asian Review 31(1), pp. 66–81.
  46. Jonsson S. (2020). ʻA society which is not: Political emergence and migrant agencyʼ. Current Sociology Monograph 68(2), pp. 204–222.
  47. Kelly A. (2016). Nestlé admits slavery in Thailand while fighting child labour lawsuit in Ivory Coast, Theguardian.com. Available online: https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2016/feb/01/nestle-slavery-thailand-fighting-child-labour-lawsuit-ivory-coast [19.02.2021].
  48. Kerr K. (2010). Defendant surrenders in human trafficking case: U.S. prosecutors want him held without bail as 'flight risk', Kitv.com. Available online: www.kitv.com/r /24866750/detail.html [1.11.2011].
  49. Kotecha A. (ed.) (2017). Legal Gap Analysis of Thailand's Anti-Trafficking Legislation. Washington DC: Liberty Asia Publications.
  50. Lampang Province v. Pochanee Sinchai-Loicheun (2008). Lampang Provincial Court, Thailand.
  51. LeBaron G. (2014). ʻReconceptualizing debt bondage: Debt as a class-based form of labor disciplineʼ. Critical Sociology 40(5), pp. 763–780.
  52. Malo S. (2017). Retail giant Costco wins dismissal of prawn lawsuit over Thai forced labor, Reuters.com. Available online: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-lawsuit-costco-idUSKBN1592JC [8.02.2021].
  53. Marschke M. and Vandergeest P. (2016). ʻSlavery scandals: Unpacking labour challenges and policy responses within the off-shore fisheries sectorʼ. Marine Policy 68, pp. 39–46.
  54. Martin P. and Ruhs M. (2011). ʻLabor shortages and the US immigration reform: Promises and perils of an independent commissionʼ. International Migration Review 45(1), pp. 174–187.
  55. Mendoza M. (2015). Nestle confirms labor abuse among its Thai seafood suppliers. Associated Press Explores: Seafood from slaves, Ap.org. Available online: https://www.ap.org/explore/seafood-from-slaves/nestle-confirms-labor-abuse-among-its-thai-seafood-suppliers.html [22.09.2020].
  56. Mendoza M. and Mason M. (2016). Hawaiian seafood caught by foreign crews confined on boats, Apnews.com. Available online: https://apnews.com/article/39ae05f117c64a929f0f8fab091c4ee1 [11.02.2021].
  57. Moossy R.J.J. (2012). Letter to Thai Community Development Center: US v. Orion et. al. (Case Number: D.HI, 10-576). Washington D.C.: US Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division, 2.
  58. Munger F. (2015). ʻTrafficking in law: Cause lawyer, bureaucratic state and rights of human trafficking victims in Thailandʼ. Asian Studies Review 39, pp. 69–87.
  59. Musingchai C. (2008). Thailand's Experiences on Compilation of Compensation to Employee and Workersʼ Remittance Statistics. Bank of Thailand: World Bank Reports.
  60. Niesse M. (2010). ʻFBI: 6 accused in forced labor of 400 Thai workersʼ. Washington Post September 3.
  61. Otsuka K. and Yamano T. (2006). ʻIntroduction to the special issue on the role of nonfarm income in poverty reduction: Evidence from Asia and East Africaʼ. Agricultural Economics 35(3), pp. 393–397.
  62. Otsuka K. and Yamano T. (2008). The Role of Rural Labor Markets in Poverty Reduction: Evidence from Asia and East Africa. Washington: World Bank.
  63. Panigabutra-Roberts A. (2012). ʻHuman trafficking in the United States, part I. State of the knowledgeʼ. Behavioral and Social Sciences Librarian 31(3–4), pp. 138–151.
  64. Peksen D., Blanton S.L. and Blanton R.G. (2017). ʻNeoliberal politics and human trafficking for labor: Free markets, unfree workers?ʼ Political Research Quarterly 70(3), pp. 673–686.
  65. Raigrodski D. (2016). ʻCreative capitalism and human trafficking: A business approach to eliminate forced labor and human trafficking from global supply chainsʼ. William & Mary Business Law Review 8(1), pp. 71–134.
  66. Responsiblesourcingtool.org (n.d.). Responsiblesourcingtool.org. Available online: https://www.responsiblesourcingtool.org/ [28.01.2021].
  67. Royal Government of Thailand (2017). The Anti-Trafficking in Persons Act; Article No. 3.
  68. Royal Ordinance Concerning the Management of Employment of Migrant Workers (2017). National Assembly of Thailand.
  69. Sadruddin H., Walter N. and Hidalgo J. (2005). ʻHuman trafficking in the United States, expanding victim protection beyond prosecution witnessesʼ. Stanford Law & Policy Review 16, pp. 379–416.
  70. Schierup C. and Jorgensen M.B. (2016). ʻAn introduction to the special issue. Politics of precarity: Migrant conditions, struggles and experiencesʼ. Critical Sociology 42, pp. 947–958.
  71. Schmitt A. (2007). ʻEnding the silence: Thai H-2A workers, recruitment fees, and the fair labor standards actʼ. Pacific Rim Law and Policy Journal 16(1), pp. 167–196.
  72. Seedangjan P. (2007). ʻGoodbye H2Aʼ. In P. Seedangjan (ed.) Exit USA. USA: IPTV: Thai Satellite and Internet Protocol Television.
  73. Sharma N. (2005). ʻAnti-trafficking rhetoric and the making of a global apartheidʼ. NWSA Journal: Special Issue States of Insecurity and the Gendered Politics of Fear 17(3), pp. 88–111.
  74. Simmons B. and Lloyd P. (2010). Subjective frames and rational choice: Transnational crime and the case of human trafficking. Available online: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228151405_Subjective_Frames_and_Rational_Choice_Transnational_Crime_and_the_Case_of_Human_Trafficking [19.02.2021].
  75. State of California Department of Justice (2010). The California Transparency in Supply Chains Act. Available online: https://oag.ca.gov/SB657 [28.01.2021].
  76. Sud v. Costco Wholesale Corporation (2017). US District Court, Northern District of California, San Francisco. USA.
  77. Thai Community Development Center [TCDC] (2003-2012). Global Horizons Case Files.
  78. Thai Community Development Center [TCDC] (2005-2011). Global Horizons Case Files.
  79. Thai Community Development Center [TCDC] (2005-2012). Global Horizons Case Files.
  80. Thai Community Development Center [TCDC] (2007-2010). Global Horizons Case Files.
  81. Thai Union and LPN organise training session for employees on education rights to encourage migrant children to enroll in school (n.d.), Thaiunion.com. Available online: https://www.thaiunion.com/en/newsroom/press-release/101/thai-union-and-lpn-organise-training-session-for-employees-on-education-rights-to-encourage-migrant-children-to-enroll-in-school [17.02.2021].
  82. The Nation Corporate Reporter (2019). CP Foods vows to protect human rights of workers as US mounts pressure on Thailand. The Nation Bangkok: The Nation Thailand. Available online: https://www.nationthailand.com/business/30378376 [19.02.2021].
  83. Trauma-Informed Victim Interviewing (n.d.), Ovcttac.gov. Available online: https://www.ovcttac.gov/taskforceguide/eguide/5-building-strong-cases/53-victim-interview-preparation/trauma-informed-victim-interviewing/ [17.02.2021].
  84. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission [US EEOC] (2014). Judge Approves $2.4 Million EEOC Settlement with Four Hawaii Farms for over 500 Thai Farmworkers. Available online: https://www.eeoc.gov/newsroom/judge-approves-24-million-eeoc-settlement-four-hawaii-farms-over-500-thai-farmworkers [28.01.2020].
  85. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission [US EEOC] (2016). Federal Judge Awards EEOC $7,658,500 in Case Against Farm Labor Contractor Global Horizons. Available online: https://www.eeoc.gov/newsroom/federal-judge-awards-eeoc-7658500-case-against-farm-labor-contractor-global-horizons [15.09.2020].
  86. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission [US EEOC] (2020). EEOC Settles National Origin and Race Discrimination Case on Behalf of Thai Farm Workers. Available online: https://www.eeoc.gov/newsroom/eeoc-settles-national-origin-and-race-discrimination-case-behalf-thai-farm-workers [28.01.2020].
  87. United Nations (2000). U.N. Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, Supplementing the United. Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime [Palermo Protocol]. Available online: https://www.ohchr.org/en/professionalinterest/pages/protocoltraffickinginpersons.aspx [19.02.2021].
  88. United States Citizenship and Immigration Services [USCIS] (2020). Immigration and Citizenship Data. Available online: https://www.uscis.gov/tools/reports-and-studies/immigration-and-citizenship-data [15.09.2020].
  89. United States Department of State (2013). United States Trafficking in Persons Report. Washington DC: State Department. Available online: https://2009-2017.state.gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/2013//index.htm [19.02.2021].
  90. United States Department of State (2014). United States Trafficking in Persons Report. Washington DC: State Department. Available online: https://2009-2017.state.gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/2014/ [22.09.2020].
  91. United States Department of State (2016). Responsible Business Conduct: First National Action Plan for the United States of America. State Department. Washington DC: United States. Available online: https://www.state.gov/u-s-national-contact-point-for-the-oecd-guidelines-for-multinational-enterprises/u-s-national-action-plan-on-responsible-business-conduct/ [19.02.2021].
  92. United States Department of State (2020). Nonimmigrant Visa Statistics. United States Government. Available online: https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/legal/visa-law0/visa-statistics/nonimmigrant-visa-statistics.html [22.09.2020].
  93. United States Department of State (2020). United States Trafficking in Persons Report. Washington DC: State Department. Available online: https://www.state.gov/reports/2020-trafficking-in-persons-report/ [19.02.2021].
  94. United States of America (2000). ʻVictims of Trafficking and Violence Protection act of 2000ʼ. In Congress US (ed.) Public Law 106-386, [H.R. 3244]. Washington D.C.: United States Government.
  95. United States v. Orion (2010). Case opinion from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit. USA.
  96. United States v. Sou (2011). US 9th Circuit Court, Hawaii. USA.
  97. Vandergeest P. and Marschke M. (2020). ʻModern slavery and freedom: Exploring contradictions through labour scandals in the Thai fisheriesʼ. Antipode 52(1), pp. 1–25.
  98. Victim-Centered Approach (n.d.), Ovcttac.gov. Available online: https://www.ovcttac.gov/taskforceguide/eguide/1-understanding-human-trafficking/13-victim-centered-approach/ [17.02.2021].
  99. World Bank (International Bank for Reconstruction and Development) (2011). Migration and Remittances Factbook 2011. Washington DC: World Bank.
  100. Zimmerman M. (2012). ʻGlobal Horizons CEO speaks out about human trafficking allegations and the justice department's decision to drop the chargesʼ. Hawaii Reporter.