No. XXXIX (2017)
Articles

A Criminal and Political Analysis of The Spanish Gender Violence Law

Magdalena Grzyb
Jagiellonian University

Published 2017-01-02

Keywords

  • przemoc,
  • płeć,
  • ofiara przemocy,
  • kryminologia

How to Cite

Grzyb, M. (2017). A Criminal and Political Analysis of The Spanish Gender Violence Law. Archives of Criminology, (XXXIX), 339–368. https://doi.org/10.7420/AK2017L

Abstract

The Spanish Comprehensive Protection Measures against Gender Violence of 28 December 2004 (Ley Organica 1/2004, de 28 de diciembre, de Medidas de Protección Integral contra la Violencia de Género) is considered one of the most advanced and ground-breaking legal acts designed to counter gender violence and is often viewed as a model piece of legislation to be emulated by other countries. The characteristic feature of this law is the introduction of criminal-law protection for women experiencing violence from their partner.Although the Spanish law has been praised in the international arena, it has definitely elicited mixed feelings in Spain itself. It seems a paradox that one of the few laws passed in recent decades with the full consensus of all political parties instantly became one of the most criticized and subjected to judgment. Even before it entered into force, the law encountered significant criticism from the Spanish judiciary, while its application in practice has earned it further opponents and critics – nearly all of them engaged social stakeholders: feminists, legal theorists, criminologists, and victims of violence themselves. Some of the charges probably do not stem from the faulty operation or application of the law as such, but from the dashed hopes and disappointed expectations, grounded in the naïve belief that the new law would quickly transform society and eradicate gender violence.The aim of the article is to sum up ten years of the gender violence law in Spain. The first part outlines the origins of LO 1/2004, its historical and political background, including the fall of Franco’s dictatorship and the later socialist government whose rule led to increased interest in gender equality and the introduction of measures to counter all instances of discrimination in addition to raising public awareness of violence against women starting in the 1990s.The second part discusses the content of LO 1/2004 and explains why the Spanish legislators adopted the gender violence framework (instead of the neutral ‘domestic violence’ model, as referenced in Polish and other national legislations), which recognises that women are disproportionally more prone to certain forms of violence, particularly on the part of relatives and partners, which is due to structural inequality and centuries-old historical discrimination of women. Gender violence is an infringement of human and women’s rights and, as such, should be combated. The ‘gender violence’ approach is also currently the dominant perspective in international human rights discourse and international documents. The third part discusses controversies that have arisen in connection with the law and examines the main charges put against it. The introduction of LO 1/2004 has raised doubts as to its being consistent with the constitutional principle of equality before the law. The Spanish Constitutional Tribunal decided this issue in favour of the law in 2008. The law might also make the situation of certain victims more complicated, as it imposes very strict and punitive solutions, thus stripping them of subjectivity. The law has moreover encountered strong opposition from the judiciary itself, which wasn’t pleased with it from the very beginning. Finally, the Author examines various figures related to gender violence and how they have evolved over the ten years since the law entered into force.Part four is devoted to the amendment of Spanish criminal law in 2015 to take account of gender violence, and discusses the direction of legislative and criminal/political changes.The final part consists of a summary and an attempt to provide a comprehensive assessment of the law since it was passed.

References

  1. Blay Gil E., ‘Voy o no voy’. El recurso a la Policia en el caso de la violencia de genero. Perspectiva de las victimas, „Estudios Penales y Criminologicos” 2013, t. XXXIII.
  2. Bonino L., Micromachismos: La violencia invisible en la pareja (1998), http://www.joaquimmontaner.net/Saco/dipity_mens/micromachismos_0.pdf [dostęp: 20.06.2016].
  3. Carmona Vergara A., Reformas legislativas recientes sobre violencia de género, 25 listopada 2015, http://www.abogacia.es/2015/11/25/reformas-legislativas-recientes-sobre-violencia-de-genero/ [dostęp: 20.06.2016].
  4. Consejo General del Poder Judicial, Estudio sobre la aplicación de le ley integral contra la violencia de genero por las Audiencias Provincionales, Marzo 2016.
  5. Consejo General del Poder Judicial, Estudio sobre la aplicación de la Ley Integral contra la violencia de genero por las Audiencias Provincionales, Septiembre 2009.
  6. Decyzja Komitetu CEDAW z 15 sierpnia 2014r., 47/2012, Dokument nr CEDAW/C/58/D/47/2012.
  7. Deklaracja o Eliminacji Przemocy wobec Kobiet przyjętej przez Zgromadzenie Ogólne NZ 20 grudnia 1993 r., Rezolucja 48/104.
  8. Dyduch X., Przemoc wobec kobiet w hiszpańskim systemie prawnym. Sądy ds. przemocy wobec kobiet, „Czasopismo Prawa Karnego i Nauk Penalnych” 2012, R. XVI, z. 2.
  9. Emerson Dobash R., Dobash R.P., When Men Murder Women, Oxford University Press, Oxford, New York 2015.
  10. Entrevista – Ana Llorca, Jueza de Violencia sobre la Mujer „Los casos más graves de violencia de género no llegan al Juzgado”, „El Diario” z 26.10.2014, http://www.eldiario.es/norte/navarra/ultima_hora/graves-violencia-genero-llegan-Juzgado_0_317068702.html [dostęp: 22.11.2014].
  11. Fiscalia General del Estado, Memoria 2014, Madrid 2014.
  12. Gregory A., On the outside looking in: The shared burden of domestic violence [nieopublikowana praca doktorska], University of Bristol, Bristol 2014.
  13. Johnson M.P., Patriarchal terrorism and common couple violence. Two forms of violence against women, „Journal of Marriage and the Family” 1995, nr 57.
  14. Konwencja Rady Europy o zapobieganiu i zwalczaniu przemocy wobec kobiet i przemocy domowej przyjęta w Stambule 11 maja 2011 r., Council of Europe Treaty Series No 210.
  15. Larrauri E., Cinco topicos sobre las mujeres victimas de violencia y algunas respuestas del feminismo oficial, Genero, Violencia y Derecho, Tirant lo Blanch, Valencia 2008.
  16. Larrauri Pijoan E., Igualdad y violencia de genero, „InDret. Revista Para el Analisis del Derecho” luty 2009.
  17. Laurenzo Copello P., La violencia de genero en la ley integral. Valoración politico-criminal, „Revista Electronica de Ciencia Penal y Criminologia” z 7.08.2005 r.
  18. Lewoc M., Prokuratura i sądownictwo przeciw przemocy w rodzinie w 2015 r., „Niebieska Linia” 2016, nr 3.
  19. Ley Organica 1/2004, de 28 de diciembre, de Medidas de Protección Integral contra la Violencia de Género.
  20. Lorente Acosta M., La estafa piramidal de las denuncias falsas, „El Diario” z 24.11.2014 r., http://www.eldiario.es/agendapublica/impacto_social/estafa-piramidal-denuncias-falsas_0_327917529.html [dostęp: 25.12.2016].
  21. Machado Ruiz M.D., La perspectiva de genero en el derecho comparado [w:] P. Laurenzo Copello (red.), La Violencia de Genero en la Ley. Reflexiones sobre veinte ańos de experiencia en Espana, Dykinson, Madrid 2010.
  22. Maqueda Abreu M.L., 1989-2009: Veinte ańos de „desconcierto” entre la ley penal y la realidad de la violencia en la pareja [w:] P. Laurenzo Copello (red.), La Violencia de Genero en la Ley. Reflexiones sobre veinte ańos de experiencia en Espana, Dykinson, Madrid 2010.
  23. Ministerio de Sanidad, Servicios Sociales e Igualdad, VII Informe Annual del Obsrvatorio Estatal de Violencias sobre la Mujer 2013.
  24. Molina Caballero M.J., Reflexiones acerca del estatus de la victima en los procesos sobre violencia de genero [w:] P. Laurenzo Copello (red.), La Violencia de Genero en la Ley. Reflexiones sobre veinte ańos de experiencia en Espana, Dykinson, Madrid 2010.
  25. Nowakowska U., Ministerstwo Sprawiedliwości odmówiło przyznania dotacji Centrum Praw Kobiet, „Wysokie Obcasy” z 18.06.2016 r.
  26. Paul Velasco J.M. de, Aspectos penales de la L.O. 1/2004. Experiencias de su aplicación [w:] P. Laurenzo Copello (red.), La Violencia de Genero en la Ley. Reflexiones sobre veinte ańos de experiencia en Espana, Dykinson, Madrid 2010.
  27. ¿QUÉ JUSTICIA ESPECIALIZADA? A siete años de la Ley Integral contra la Violencia de Género. Obstáculos al acceso y obtención de justicia y protección, Amnesty International Spain, Madrid 2012.
  28. Rubio A., La ley Integral: entre el desconcierto del genero y la eficacia impuesta [w:] P. Laurenzo Copello (red.), La Violencia de Genero en la Ley. Reflexiones sobre veinte ańos de experiencia en Espana, Dykinson, Madrid 2010.
  29. Sanz-Barbero B., Vives-Cases C., Otero-Garcia L., Muntaner C., Turrabiano-Dominguez J., O’Campo P., Intimate Partner Violence among women in Spain. The impact of regional-level male unemployment and income inequality, „European Journal of Public Health” 2015, t. 25, nr 6.
  30. Subijana Zunzunegui I.J., La igualdad y la violencia de genero en el orden jurisdiccional penal, „Revista Electrónica de Ciencia Penal y Criminología” z 12.05.2010 r.
  31. Ten Years of Austrian Anti-Violence Legislation, Bundeskanzleram Frauen, Vienna 2008.
  32. Valiente C., Spain at the Vanguard in European Gender Equality Policies [w:] S. Roth (red.), Gender politics in the expanding European Union: Mobilization, inclusion, exclusion, Berghahn, New York 2008.
  33. Violence against Women: and EU-wide survey Fundamental Rights Agency (FRA), Vienna 2014.